Friday, March 8, 2013

Comparing the Newark Museum and the MoMA today



Newark Museum

Our class visited the Newark Museum and was given a tour by Pat Wessel. Throughout the tour she explained that the main goal of the Newark Museum is to educate, saying that the museum’s job is to teach. The museum was originally a family’s land turned into a museum. The collection first started off as a donated collection. It expanded as more donations were made. Some pieces are bought by selling some donations that don’t fit the museum’s collections. For example, the museum does not have a lot of European art. If, for example, they receive a 17th century European oil painting, they may have to think about what collections they have that are missing works from certain time periods so they can sell the European piece and fill in the gap. They also receive works from buildings that are being taken down that have murals (basically, more donations).

The audience of the institution is vast, ranging from college students to business people on their breaks. However, there is a special focus on the community and educating the youth. In their aim to educate, a lot of the pieces they collect are functional, domestic pieces so that kids can relate to the objects they are seeing.

The museum definitely focuses on history by creating special exhibitions for different cultures and setting up works in chronological order. For example, when we visited the African exhibits, one room consisted of very old artifacts. That exhibition space connected to a contemporary African art gallery, thus giving a historical perspective for a viewer of contemporary art. It teaches history by the placement of certain artifacts and artworks in chronological order. To make an exhibit more interactive, the museum makes sure to use multi-media sources, new technology, to engage and teach the viewer. Labels are a major component since the aim is to teach. Also, the variation in time periods is so vast that labels are important. The 1st floor has ancient art and contemporary galleries and the top floor have modern and contemporary galleries. Considering the range, labels are vital to creating coherent exhibitions. Also, creating environments using different mediums of art (such as furniture with paintings) adds to the success of these exhibitions.

Since there are so many different exhibits, there are different curators that specialize in certain time periods of art that curate and put together shows. Part of the curator’s job is to see what is missing from a collection. Perhaps a type of functional artifact isn't in a specific exhibit; for example, shoes. Maybe there is a whole gap of time not represented in an exhibit. Those are some of the many things curators may look for. If a curator does decided to buy a certain piece, they must propose it to the board and convince them why it is important for the museum to have a certain item in their collection.

They also have exhibition spaces for the sciences and site local resources to teach kids about geography and other sciences. A major component of the Newark museum is to educate the youth through various workshops. They rely on volunteers for this type of education; Pat is actually a volunteer. Tours and workshops, main components of educating, are done by volunteers due to the lack of funding.

A lot of the funding is usually by the state, but those funds have been cut. The hardest thing for the museum to fund every day is operational costs. They rely heavily on donations by over 30 different foundations. Foundations and volunteers, as well as people wanting to show their collections (or donate them) provide substance for the museum to function. 

Though the Newark Museum does have older works, it does seek to give light to overlooked art makers of the past. For example, currently on display is the exhibit “In Her Eyes: Women Behind and in Front of the Camera.” This exhibit feature only female artists of many different cultures. In the past, art history barely mentioned female artists as well as artists of different cultures. This exhibition helps fill in that gap.


MoMA

As with the Newark Museum, the MoMA’s role is also to educate. The audience of the institution is very vast. They have visitors worldwide varying in all fields. Part of their job, as with many museums, is to affirm notions of art history. This is reiterated in “Civilizing Rituals: inside public art museums” by carol Duncan when she states “Their curatorial staffs many share many of the views of their academic colleagues; but, the government-supported and/or tax-free public institutions in which they work are under pressure to present forms of knowledge that have recognizable meaning and value for a broader community.”(Duncan 103) Our tour guide, Steven Wheeler, even stated that some pieces need to stay up because people would get mad if it was taken down. He was referring to Van Gogh’s Starry Night in the 5th floor. The top two floors are dedicated to presenting most of the key figures in modern art (in the mediums of painting and sculpture). Those are basically the ones that keep visitors coming, as they seek to see work that they have been taught to be important. Of course, the museum does aim to do more than to just affirm academia’s map of art history.

The contemporary galleries are quite a sight. The new exhibit “Applied Design” definitely gave the one time visitor an eye full. It did not really affirm any notions of art history. In fact, I was surprised to see most of that stuff in the MoMA. The exhibition basically showed different physical manifestations of design concepts, whether they be functional or fantastical. One side of the room focused on design and functionality in the home; furniture. The other side highlighted scientific tools and design as well as virtual worlds (aka video games)! It was an amazing exhibition and there was so much to learn about the application of design in a vast range of fields, not just in fine art.

Labeling is very important in both museums but it was especially relevant in the “Applied Design” exhibit. Since the exhibited pieces had an engineering and architectural basis, variation in labeling text and the use of videos was key. The function of some objects had to be clearly explained in a small box of text or visually demonstrated.
The curators are important for the same reason as in the Newark Museum. They also may use works to sell and use the money to buy works that fit a certain time period.  
The MoMA has more contemporary art galleries, so they have a bigger concern for showing new art than the Newark Museum. Also, since it is a modern art gallery, of course they don’t exhibit any pieces before the modern art period. Furthermore, the MoMA’s floors are divided by medium (Architecture and Design I, Painting and Drawing I, etc.) as opposed to the Newark Museum, who creates environments of a certain time period using different pieces (furniture, painting, etc.).

Both museums made me think about notions of art history that I have learned and accepted throughout my art education. It also made me think about the possibilities of exhibiting pieces that don’t necessarily fit within these notions. The exhibits at the MoMA really opened my eyes to those possibilities. The Newark Museum demonstrated the idea of creating an environment in a gallery, not just using it as a display area. The “Applied Design” exhibit at the MoMA and the many exhibits at the Newark Museum use the construction of an environment to display certain pieces.

In terms of art making, I have thought about the merging of disciplines and fields of study to create functional and non-functional art pieces. The MoMA had me thinking about the possibilities of creating functional artistic pieces and having it fall into multiple categories. Science and design have had amazing outcomes, as demonstrated in “Applied Design.”  

From "Applied Design"






Newark Museum links:


MoMA links:


No comments:

Post a Comment